Clay County, the Ten Commandments, and the Constitution
The Clay County Commission and the Ten Commandments are in the news again:
CHARLESTON, W.Va. (AP) — The Clay County Commission voted unanimously before an audience of nearly 200 Wednesday to leave a plaque of the Ten Commandments on the wall of its chamber.
The plaque is one of several historical documents — which include the Bill of Rights — that are on display, said Commissioner Jimmy Sams. The display has been up for several years.
I’ve mentioned this before, and really, I only bring it up because I feel the need to respond to this:
County resident Jesse Sizemore has asked the commission several times to remove the Ten Commandments, citing the constitutional requirement of separation of church and state.
As simply and clearly as possible: There is no Constitutional requirement of separation of church and state.
The word “church” doesn’t appear in the Constitution. The word “religion” only appears in the first Amendment to the Constitution, which reads:
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
Even allowing that the Fourteenth Amendment extends the protection of our rights to the local level (which it really doesn’t — it says “State“), displaying the Ten Commandments is not an establishment of religion. We don’t require citizens to recite the Commandments, nor do we ask them to swear that they follow them. It’s merely a display that symbolizes the historical and cultural influences on our county.
As I said in the post I linked before, I really don’t care all that much about this issue on its own merits. The Ten Commandments are an important part of my religious beliefs, and I like having them there as they’re a nice nod to the culture of our county, but I don’t see having them taken down as a slap in the face. If we had a decent-sized Muslim community, I’d be okay with displaying some symbol of their beliefs, too. The same would be true of Buddhists, Hindu, or members of any other faith.
However, I have a huge issue with the attitude of modern America that the Federal Government should stick its nose into every little aspect of our life. This is a local government issue, and as it doesn’t involve the infringement of any right, those wanting to bring in the Feds should shut up and nominate an anti-Ten Commandments candidate to take the plaque down.